Resources on Moncrieff v Jamieson

The following is a list of resources on Moncrieff v Jamieson with links or downloads where this is available online:-

From Scotland

Moncrieff v Jamieson 2004 SCLR 135; [2005] CSIH 14, 2005 SC 281, 2005 SLT 225, 2005 SCLR 463; [2007] UKHL 42, 2007 SLT 989, 2007 SCLR 790

Law Lords uphold parking servitude right,, News, 23 October 2007

R Paisley, 'Clear View' (2007) 52 JLSS Dec p50

Hector MacQueen, Setting Down with Da Cars in "Da Store", University of Edinburgh - Scots Law News

K G C Reid and G L Gretton, ‘Car parking in paradise’, Conveyancing 2007 pp 106 – 117

D Bartos, ‘Advance to Free Parking?’ (2007) 75 Scottish Law Gazette 203: Download the PDF article (115 KB)

G Junor, ‘Warning – parking problems ahead (Moncrieff v Jamieson applied)’ SLT 2008, 1, 1-2

Craig Blackwood, 'Servitudes and shop fronts' (2008) JLSS Sep

Hector MacQueen, 'Psst, want to download a video about servitudes?', University of Edinburgh - Scots Law News, 21 October 2008

Kenneth Mackay, 'Servitudes - new ground?' Whether the Lords' decision in Moncrieff v Jamieson has really advanced the law, or simply created fresh uncertainty (2009) 54 JLSS p50

Hector MacQueen, 'Servitudes of Parking: Scots and English Law'. University of Edinburgh - Scots Law News, 3 April 2009

Inksters' Legal News (4 April 2009): Court of Appeal considers Moncrieff v Jamieson in the case of Waterman v Boyle [2009] EWCA (Civ) 115.

Holms v Ashford Estates Limited [2009] CSIH 28; 2009 SLT 389 - Interesting analysis of "ouster" principle in Moncrieff v Jamieson.

SP Distribution Ltd v Rafique 2009 GWD 40-688 - Express servitude of access to cellars did not include by implication a right to construct a flight of steps. Reference to Moncrieff v Jamieson and ancillary rights.

Garson v McLeish 11 December 2009, Kirkwall Sheriff Court - Cannot extend an access road to include the verge as this would alter the nature of the road in a manner that would increase the burden on the servient tenement. Reference to Moncrieff v Jamieson at paragraphs 76 and 78.

An English Perspective

G C Seabourne, 'Servitudes and car parking', Common Lawyer, 18 October 2007

G C Seabourne, 'More on Moncrieff: Anglo-Scottish concord on car parking', Common Lawyer, 19 October 2007

Can you claim an implied 'right to park' as an easement?, The Practical Lawyer, January 2008

Emma Slessenger, ‘Car Parking Rules OK’ Conv. 2008, 3, 188

April Stroud, Making Sense of Land Law (Second Edition), Chapter 17: Easements